Argument: They're just making things up as they go along!!!

If you are in the middle of a sentence—like I have been multiple times already—you have no idea how you're going to finish it. You're not planning sentences. You didn't come up with the sentence. These are spewing out of you just like an LLM. You are just as surprised about anything you say as the person receiving it.

Here's another example. What are your top seven favorite restaurants in the entire world? You've got 30 seconds. What is your brain doing right now? Where is that content coming from?

If I ask you multiple weeks apart, the list will be different because some you couldn't remember at the time. Your preference might have changed in between. This is not a static, cohesive, dependable process.